Loading...
 

'Beatles vs. Stones' puts a new spin on an age-old debate

McMillian offers fresh insight into the dynamics of both the Beatles and the Rolling Stones as they grew and changed, with a real-time and palpable sense of excitement.

Image

  • LENNY W. DOOLAN
  • PAPERBACK WRITER: John McMillian's Beatles vs. Stones offers a different take on an age-old feud.

Author John McMillian wants to make one thing clear: He is a historian, not a rock critic. It is precisely for this reason that he doesn't pick a side in the age-old debate that stands as the title for his second book: Beatles vs. Stones (Simon & Schuster 320 pages, $26). After all, what is there that's left to be said about such a tired debate in 2013? As it turns out, there's still plenty to be said. But for McMillian, who works as an assistant professor of history at Georgia State University, it's not about riffing on which band had a better drummer, and whose records were chock-full of filler. "I have always been obsessed with both groups; the Beatles and the Rolling Stones are two of my favorite bands," McMillian says. "But I didn't want to allow myself to get drawn into a debate over which one is better, and have readers approach the book as if it was a treatise on behalf of one sensibility or the other."

Rather, Beatles vs. Stones takes on a wholly different angle on how the greatest rock 'n' roll rivalry of all time was fostered by the fans, the music industry, the media, and by the bands themselves. By bringing to light mounds of source materials that most scholars and critics have never mined, namely the alternative newspapers and fan magazines of the late '60s and early '70s, McMillian taps into the stories of both bands as they unfold. By tracing their evolutions, side-by-side, as they appeared in the underground publications of the times, McMillian offers fresh insight into the dynamics of both groups as they grew and changed, with a real-time and palpable sense of excitement.

Continue reading ...



More By This Writer

Article

Monday November 4, 2019 08:02 am EST
Singer and bass player Philip Frobos talks about coming up in Atlanta's music scene and signing with Sub Pop | more...

Article

Friday October 25, 2019 10:00 am EDT
Brother Hawk and Soloriens Native Unity Quartet return, and more new releases | more...

Article

Friday October 25, 2019 08:49 am EDT
Tom Cheshire and Casey Yarbrough talk the songs of the Ramones and coming of age in Atlanta | more...

Article

Thursday October 24, 2019 10:58 am EDT
Brazen Youth at Masquerade, Night of 1,000 Covers at the Bakery, Shepherds’ Insignificant Whip LP release show at 529, and more | more...

Article

Tuesday October 22, 2019 11:20 am EDT
Explore these music venues that remind you how much you love the great outdoors | more...
Search for more by Chad Radford

[Admin link: 'Beatles vs. Stones' puts a new spin on an age-old debate]