Editor's Note - Hate magnet

Harm or good?

In 1939, after the Nazis invaded Czechoslovakia, my father and his brothers fled to the Middle East. The three young men left their sister and mother behind, thinking they'd lay a path for the women to follow. But Ida and Franci Edelstein, with many of their relatives, died in Auschwitz. The decision not to bring them along haunted my father for the rest of his days.

Now, here I am, nearly 70 years after my father's escape, editing a newspaper whose website is attracting a boatload of anti-Semitic comments. Many are the most hateful brand of comments – the same things the Nazis said before they slaughtered millions of innocents and started a world war. With added insult that the slaughter never happened. Or was justified. Or, somehow, both.

The onslaught started last month when John Sugg wrote a cover story about a white-supremacist website. That drew thousands of readers and hundreds of comments from racists. Most were just plain nasty and ignorant. Some opined on an editor's note I placed under John's story on the Web, which explained that we weren't censoring the comments, even if we found them ugly.

One responded with rage that I wouldn't face him in "one-on-one debate." How dare I call his racist comments "hateful"! But another said I "should be congratulated" for allowing the hateful comments to stay up. A surprising decision from a Jew! I must be a credit to my race.

Over the last few weeks, a small cadre of racists has stuck around to comment on all sorts of CL stories. A column on free speech that John wrote harshly referenced a Jewish critic of Jimmy Carter's recent book on Palestine. The racists took it as an opportunity to pipe in comments even more disgusting than before.

Apparently, we're now on the racists' radar. I even got a letter last week seeking coverage from a Holocaust-denying Georgia State University professor (see Andisheh Nouraee's post on our Fresh Loaf blog).

All of which leaves me with two questions. The first is: Where do these people come from? Most, apparently, reveal their true feelings only anonymously on the Web. Who are they? Was one the waiter who filled my cup this morning? Or the car salesman who seemed a bit less sincere than even most car salesmen do? Are they just a handful of people commenting over and over? Or are there many more people than we ever realized infected by this particular brand of evil?

The other question is this: Do we do harm by amplifying the haters' comments or good by letting our audience see how ugly the haters are?


More By This Writer


Wednesday November 19, 2008 04:57 am EST

Huffington Post reported this afternoon that former Veep Al Gore will campaign here Sunday for Democratic Senate candidate Jim Martin. I'm sure Young Thomas will be getting us more details later.

Meanwhile, here are details on former President Bill Clinton's visit tomorrow (or today by the time you read this) at Clark Atlanta University on behalf of Martin. For those keeping score, John...

| more...


Monday November 17, 2008 02:35 pm EST

1. Serious injury at Atlanta Downhill Soapbox Derby By Andisheh Nouraee

2. Paul Broun compares Obama to Hitler By Andisheh Nouraee

3. Atlanta's 11 Least Influential People: No. 6 By Andisheh Nouraee

4. Atlanta's 11 Least Influential People: No. 7 By Andisheh Nouraee

5. Wendy Whitaker faces under court ruling By Scott Henry

| more...


Saturday November 15, 2008 02:27 pm EST

Creative Loafing Inc. has asked a bankruptcy judge to allow it to pay $495 an hour to the investment banker who engineered last year's purchase by CL of two other alternative weeklies, according to Atlanta Magazine's Steve Fennessy. This time Skyway Capital Partners' Bryan Crino would be tasked with helping to solve the company's financial woes.

Under the company's Nov. 10 motion to the...

| more...


Monday November 10, 2008 11:17 pm EST

After eight years during which the federal government didn't even have an urban policy, an aide  President-elect Obama is indicating that he plans to coordinate aid to cities.

The Washington Post reports that Obama plans to establish a White House Office of Urban Policy.

"He's going to have a White House chief of urban policy," transition co-chair Valerie Jarrett told the Trotter...

| more...


Monday November 10, 2008 03:17 pm EST

1. AJC censors comics, movie ads By Scott Henry

2. Georgia Court of Appeals: The most important vote you may skip on Tuesday By Ken Edelstein

3. Election night photos By Alejandro A. Leal

4. Atlanta's Ebenezer Baptist Obama celebration photos By Thomas Wheatley

5. The Libertarian effect on Georgia's U.S. Senate race By Thomas Wheatley

| more...
Search for more by Ken Edelstein

[Admin link: Editor's Note - Hate magnet]