Loading...
 

Bloomsbury's bad decision turns it into a 'Liar'

When I was at Book Expo America back in May, one of the "must-grab" pre-publication books (called ARCs, or advance reader copies) handed out like candy was a young adult novel by Justine Larbalestier called Liar, about a young girl whose world of pathological untruths slowly dissolves around the reader. It's an amazing, dark and disturbing story that leaves pretty much every question unanswered (you may hate that, but it's the sort of device I can't get enough of in books, and, for a YA book it's really heavy and high-level). This is the cover (at right), as done by Larbalestier's American publisher, Bloomsbury (Liar has already been out for a minute in her native Australia)

Almost immediately upon cracking that book's spine, though, what you'll find is that Micah, the teenage girl narrator, is, as the author describes her, "black with nappy hair which she wears natural and short."

Anything discordant with that statement when you look at the cover?

Exactly.

I hadn't started reading Liar when news began to break of Larbalestier's distaste for what she termed a "whitewashing" of her book,  but when I did, despite the book's creepily compelling plot and a narrator constantly shifting from reliable to untrustable, that cover, the little white girl with the straight hair and the big eyes, kept pulling me back out. Bleeding-edge New York-based lit critique blog and performance group Fiction Circus took that sense of disconnect all the way to the mat when it caught wind of what was going on:

"If a black cover is an absolute deal-breaker, THEN USE SOME OTHER IMAGE. Like, the word "Liar" up in flames. Or a central image from the text. A broken mirror. ANYTHING. Don't put a little white girl on the front of your book about a little black girl. It's going to change people's ideas about the narrative, which is primarily a story about identity in the first place."



More By This Writer

Article

Wednesday June 16, 2010 09:00 am EDT
New novel surpasses his career-defining work in beautiful, timely nihilism | more...

Article

Monday June 29, 2009 09:44 pm EDT

image-1

Get this: apparently, being a New York Times-bestselling author of only occasionally tropey chicklit (but, to be fair, sometimes really awesome fantastical lit-fic) means that you get to act like an utter jerk on the interwebs!

When Boston Globe critic Roberta Silman dared to say things about Alice Hoffman's new book, The Story Sisters, such as "this new novel lacks the spark...

| more...

Article

Thursday May 21, 2009 02:55 pm EDT

In terms of parenting, bad can be relative.

image-1

In 2005, when Ayelet Waldman — lawyer/author/wife of Pulitzer Prize-winning author Michael Chabon (The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay, probably the best book about comics that I'll never read, and The Mysteries of Pittsburgh, probably the best book about the mysteries of Pittsburgh that I'll never read ) — wrote in...

| more...

Article

Wednesday May 13, 2009 07:30 am EDT
All's fair in trailer park love and war | more...

Article

Wednesday May 6, 2009 08:53 pm EDT

image-1

An imagined conversation between two average bookish dorks:

“So, what’d you do over the weekend?”

“Me? Not much. Went to Superman Jack Sparrow’s Ye Olde Comiques for Free Comic Book Day and got a pretty cool free exclusive Wolverine vs Karl Rove comic, listened to that awesome new Wilco-covering-Janelle Monae-covering-Sinatra 7-inch I picked up...

| more...
Search for more by Russ Marshalek

[Admin link: Bloomsbury's bad decision turns it into a 'Liar']

Spider for Bloomsbury's bad decision turns it into a 'Liar'