Corkscrew - Bottle shocked

Putting a cork in Bottle Shock

"You're a snob. ... it limits you." – Bill Pullman's character, Jim Barrett, in Bottle Shock

I wanted to like it, but I just couldn't. I'd love to have another shot of wine enthusiasm infused into the American bloodstream, but the stereotypes and the forced, reeking romanticism just felt too ... too much like a Napa Valley tourism ad mingled with unfinished characters. I was woefully disappointed.

Bottle Shock ain't Sideways.

If you're a wine geek, you've heard of it and may have even entered the opening on your Blackberry; if you're not, don't expect much. It opened Aug. 15 (Aug. 6 in limited release and later in some areas), and my husband and I were two of the first people to see it on the big screen. At 11:10 a.m. on a rainy Friday morning, the mostly empty theater wasn't exactly brimming with eager expectation as we were surrounded by the bored, the retired and the giddy oenophiles. Who else would see this movie?

It opened well enough, with the rolling vineyard vistas floating from the screen like scenes from my dreams. But after that five-minute nirvana, the pleasure ended and settled into an incomplete dullness.

The movie, for those who haven't indulged yet, is about a struggling lawyer-cum-winemaker who mortgages his life – including his marriage, apparently – to live the wine fantasy in budding Napa Valley. In pot-smokin' 1976, straight-laced and Hemingway-quoting Jim Barrett of Chateau Montelena pursues his quixotic ambition to produce "the perfect wine." Along comes the big, bad Brit, Steve Spurrier, played as a brilliant and delicious elitist by Alan Rickman, who owns a tragically Francophile wine shop in Paris. In playful U.S.-vs.-France conversations with his amusingly pretentious American neighbor Maurice – performed by real-life oenophile Dennis Farina – Steve cooks up a way to settle the argument: Pit California versus France in a blind taste test. Steve heads to Napa Valley to choose the opponents but, to his dismay, becomes enamored of the wine, the food and, begrudgingly, the people. Once he's back home in Paris, the Napa wines go cork to cork against pedigreed French adversaries (aka "The Judgment of Paris"). The rest is history, since Bottle Shock is based loosely on a true story. Emphasis on the loosely part.

Perhaps to make it more palatable for the masses, the producers crammed loads of formulaic Hollywood into two hours – the down-and-out dreamer, the obligatory hot and free-spirited chick and ensuing romance(s), the privileged loser son, the hardworking immigrant who "worships the sanctity of the vine," the subtle-yet-incessant French bashing and, of course, the "America triumphs" theme – and the wine is virtually overshadowed, leaving swaths of missed opportunities. They brushed over the idea of terroir and vineyard management, not explaining how important soil and climate are in quality grape growing (which played an important role in why Napa won). French oak barrels showed up as well, but the characters didn't talk about why they were used. I didn't get it: Our attention was rapt with the romance of the vine – don't they want to educate us? Perhaps they thought that might bore the average, nongeek viewer.

I disagree. Although some scenes, such as the discolored chardonnay explanation, have some educational value, the rest of the movie falls into a predictable plot. Maybe I'm being too critical, but it's far from a wine geek's ideal flick, either. And I'm not sure it will do more than sell a helluva lot of Chateau Montelena wines. Ironic, since this July they were purchased by French Bordeaux producer Cos d'Estournel.

Recommended Wines

Folonari 2006 Riesling Provincia di Pavia (Italy) Recession buster! Smells like canned fruit cocktail, but don't hold that against it. It's a simple afternoon quaffer, dripping with tropical fruit, honeydew and pineapple, but also pretty dry. Sw = 2. $9. 3 stars

Sweetness (Sw) rating is out of 10, 10 being pure sugar. Star) rating is out of 5, 5 being wine nirvana.

More By This Writer


Wednesday September 2, 2009 04:00 am EDT

This refreshing rosé blend made from grenache, shiraz, cabernet sauvignon and dolcetto (an Italian grape) smells like sweet, perfumey fruit. On the tongue, itís soft íní elegant, with cranberry, sweet cherry, ripe strawberries and fresh, lively acidity. Quite perfect, really. Perfect for any occasion, even happy ones. Sw= 2. $17 retail. 5 stars.  

Available by the bottle at 4th and Swift in...

| more...


Wednesday September 2, 2009 04:00 am EDT
What to do during life transitions | more...


Wednesday August 26, 2009 04:00 am EDT
My first Wineries that Wow entry is Sebastiani Vineyards and Winery, a family-run business that has finally turned a corner. I haven't been impressed with them in years, until I tried this fantastic pinot noir from their estate vineyards. Elegant with lush, dark cherry earthiness, excellent tart acidity and ripe plum with a flirty, sweet raspberry and strawberry finish. Luscious and worth the... | more...


Wednesday August 19, 2009 04:00 am EDT
A look at what people are drinking | more...


Thursday August 13, 2009 09:40 pm EDT
image-1I walk in the door with sweat still dewing my face, having just transitioned from goosebumpy temps at the office, walking through roasting heat, then into a baking sauna doubling as my dark-blue vehicle. In 95 degrees, the air conditioning has little hope of keeping up and it groans under the stress. I refocus on positive thoughts, the contents of my fridge: ribeye steaks, homemade... | more...
Search for more by Taylor Eason

[Admin link: Corkscrew - Bottle shocked]

Spider for Corkscrew - Bottle shocked